I thought I'd piggyback off this thread since I'm having the same issue.
I've noticed in 1.4.35 and 1.4.36 I get the same error as OP, certainly in Chrome and in Firefox I get the error "SSL_ERROR_INTERNAL_ERROR_ALERT". OpenSSL version in 1.4.34 and below uses 1.0.2 but 1.4.35> is using 1.1.1...